Hello Elroy,
Sorry for the trouble there. I took a look and the file URL that’s being specified on the front end of the site, http://www.perfectingfaithministry.org/wp/wp-content/uploads/2015/02/ThroughOneBlood_020115.mp3?_=1 , is turning up a not found error when I place the URL directly into a browser window.
The CloudFlare not found page makes me wonder if it’s not in their network for some reason, especially if you can play the file directly in the WP Media Library on your server. If you can do that, then I would try deactivating CloudFlare temporarily and see if that resolves it, once the caching has worked its way out.
Let me know how that goes.
Have a great week,
Bill