Good question. Chrome is blocking the loading of the icon font that generates the various icons in the theme since they are loading from http://gatewaychristiancenter.org and not http://mygateway.cc . It does that to prevent a cross-site attack that’s common among hackers.
I believe once the site is set to load the theme’s stylesheet and font files from http://mygateway.cc that should take care of it for you. If you’re switching domain names, it could be that the WordPress options are still set to pull from the original one.
If getting that switched doesn’t do the trick, let me know.